Track your Manuscript
Enter Correct Manuscript Reference Number:
Get Details
Top Editors
No Editor added
Top Reviewers
No Reviewer added
Why Us
Open Access
Rapid publication
Lifetime hosting
Free indexing service
Free promotion service
More citations
Search engine friendly
Go Back       Himalayan Journal of Community Medicine and Public Health | 1 1 | Oct. 5, 2020
472 Downloads1980 Views

DOI : N/A       Download PDF       HTML       XML

Severity of Diabetes in MELAS and MERRF May Rather Reflect Genotype and Comorbidities than Histology of Islet Cells

Josef Finsterer, MD, PhD1 and Marlies Frank, MD2

1Klinik Landstrasse, Messerli Institute, Vienna, Austria

2Medical Department, Klinik Landstrasse, Vienna, Austria

Article History

Received: 25.09.2020

Accepted: 04.10.2020

Published: 10.10.2020

Keywords: mtDNA, m.3243A>G, MELAS, MERRF, pancreas, diabetes, pancreatitis, autopsy .


With interest we read the article by Norose, T. et al., 2020 about the histological and immune-histological findings of islet cells in two patients with mitochondrial diabetes (Norose, T. et al., 2020). One patient was diagnosed with mitochondrial encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome due to the variant m.3243A>G (patient-1) and the second patient was diagnosed with myoclonic epilepsy with ragged-red fibers (MERRF) syndrome due to the variant m.8344A>G (Norose, T. et al., 2020). Patient-1 required insulin, whereas patient-2 did not require any anti-diabetic treatment (Norose, T. et al., 2020). It was concluded that the severity of diabetes correlates with the severity of the histological and immune-histological findings on autopsy (Norose, T. et al., 2020). We have the following comments and concerns.

We do not agree with the conclusions that the different histological findings in the two patients correlate with the severity of diabetes. First, MELAS and MERRF are completely different disorders, why simply the genotype can explain the difference between the two patients. Second, phenotypic expression of mtDNA variants strongly depends on heteroplasmy rates, mtDNA copy number, and the haplotype (Scholle, L. M. et al., 2020). Thus, it would be interesting to know if heteroplasmy rates and mtDNA copy numbers were different in islet cells or other clinically affected tissues between the two patients. We should also know if the two patients carried the same haplotype or not. Furthermore, we should know if there were alterations in the nuclear background and if the two patients had variable co-morbidities. Third, differences in histology and immune-histology could be also due to previous pancreatitis in either patient. Pancreatitis has been repeatedly reported as a clinical manifestation of mitochondrial disorder (MIDs) (Duran, G. P. et al., 2011), why we should know if the previous history was positive for acute or chronic pancreatitis in either patient or if post-mortem histological findings on autopsy were indicative of previous pancreatitis. Fourth, we should know if there were any indications for affection of the cellular immune system in either patient, which has been previously reported (Finsterer, J., & Zarrouk-Mahjoub, S. 2017), and if titers of antibodies against islet cells or mitochondria were different between the two patients.

Furthermore, we do not agree that atrophy of islet cells necessarily means reduced production of insulin. Morphology not necessarily correlates with function. Thus, we should be informed about serum insulin levels and serum levels of the C-peptide to assess if islet cell function was truly reduced or not.

Since both MELAS and MERRF syndrome are multisystem diseases, potentially affecting liver and frequently the muscle (Ban, S. et al., 1992), we should know if elevated blood glucose was due at least partially due to increased solution of liver or muscle glycogen or if gluconeogenesis was increased.

Since patient-2 had an HbA1c value of 6.9% (n, 4.6-6.2%) and diabetes was diagnosed, we should know why no anti-diabetic drugs or insulin were given. Was blood glucose well-controlled simply by diet?

Missing are the current blood chemical findings and the medication the two patients were taking at the time of decease. From various drugs it is known that they are potentially pancreato-toxic (e.g. valproic acid). Serum lactate may influence blood glucose levels as well and may have been different between the two patients.

Overall, the interesting, valuable study has some shortcomings which should be addressed before drawing final conclusions. Particularly, we need to know more about the genetic background, the current medication, and about the comorbidities of both patients before attributing different severity of diabetes only to different morphology of islet cells.


  1. Ban, S., Mori, N., Saito, K., Mizukami, K., Suzuki, T., & Shiraishi, H. (1992). An Autopsy Case of Mitochondrial Encephalomyopathy (MELAS) with SpeciaI Reference to Extra‐neuromuscular AbnormaIities. Pathology International42(11), 818-825.

  2. Duran, G. P., Martinez-Aguayo, A., Poggi, H., Lagos, M., Gutierrez, D., & Harris, P. R. (2011). Large mitochondrial DNA deletion in an infant with Addison disease. In JIMD Reports-Case and Research Reports, 2011/3 (pp. 5-9). Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg.

  3. Finsterer, J., & Zarrouk-Mahjoub, S. (2017). Affection of immune cells by a C10orf2 mutation manifesting as mitochondrial myopathy and transient sensory transverse syndrome. Acta Neurologica Belgica117(4), 969-970.

  4. Norose, T., Ito, Y., & Ohike, N. (2020). Two autopsy cases of mitochondrial disease (MELAS and MERRF) with special reference to the histological and immunohistochemical findings of the pancreatic islets. Pathology international.

  5. Scholle, L. M., Zierz, S., Mawrin, C., Wickenhauser, C., & Urban, D. L. (2020). Heteroplasmy and Copy Number in the Common m. 3243A> G Mutation—A Post-Mortem Genotype–Phenotype Analysis. Genes11(2), 212.


Copyright © 2020 Inlight Publisher (IARCON INTERATIONAL LLP). All Rights Reserved.